The six-lane Inner Loop highway that had for decades divided the eastern part of Rochester, New York, was removed and replaced in 2018 with new complete streets. Create 'shared value' for the long-term public interest. How do you derive that from No.4? Urban renewal which may be also known as urban … Many theories of "urban renewal" seemed to assume that living in the city was undesirable. Urban renewal is critical issue, not just for Africa but for the entire world. Balancing society. Erteilung oder Widerruf von Einwilligungen, klicken Sie hier: The renewal must be planned and implemented (to preserve the substance) with the current residents and business owners. Domestic Properties 1. The Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) a leading body for spatial, sustainable and inclusive planning and the largest planning institute in Europe has studied how planning has worked in a number of settings and identified the following principles that strategic planning should follow, irrespective of location. All of them, however, are linked to the same idea: to transform urban spaces in order to rejuvenate them. The best goals will be specific and measurable, and anticipate the physical, economic and social results of the project. Jane Jacobs OC OOnt (née Butzner; May 4, 1916 – April 25, 2006) was an American-Canadian journalist, author, theorist, and activist who influenced urban studies, sociology, and economics.Her book entitled, The Death and Life of Great American Cities (1961), argued that "urban renewal" and "slum clearance" did not respect the needs of city-dwellers. Each of these processes therefore generates different results. From Urban Renewal to Highway Removal Advocates — and planners — are pushing to tear down the freeways that divided and bulldozed Black neighborhoods. 2 The foundation of urban renewal must be formed by the real agreement between users and precaution appliers. Local characteristics and peculiarities should be captured and incorporated into the new project. July 3, 2017, Urban rejuvenation projects are most successful if they are designed with shared community goals in mind. Photo by Elisa Greco/Flickr. Finding ways to include more participation could improve success rates. “Ultimately, the ‘communities’ for whom the value is created to share, should be those with long-term interests, not transient stakeholders with a primary focus on value extraction and repatriation,” write the authors. Even so, a long-term vision should be locked in and changes for the sake of short-terms gains resisted, with flexibility growing as the timeline extends further into the future. All those who are part of the broader community as a whole – from workers and tourists, children and students, to the underserved and investors – should benefit from urban renewal. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Planners bringing an intervention into an existing space should share their vision and include people in the planning from day one, or risk it being rejected.    Urban renewal and urban regeneration have very similar meanings and both involve work of a relatively large scale: urban renewal is defined as the process of slum clearance and physical redevelopment that takes account of other elements such as heritage preservation (Couch, Sykes, & Boerstinghaus, 2011); while urban regeneration is a comprehensive integration of vision and action … The unique character of Kreuzberg must be preserved, while trust and optimism must be restored in the at-risk city districts. objectives of urban renewal in Hong Kong. Jacobs opposed large, complex urban renewal projects that destroyed and divided neighborhoods and argued for communities that possessed diversity and a blending of uses. Decision-making techniques such as cost-benefit analysis should be explained and employed to also promote “non-financial values,” helping communities feel a sense of ownership. Funds must be available rapidly and invested appropriately. Claude H. Boistière, of the French Ministry of Reconstruction and Housing, identified the different approaches to urban renewal as rehabilitation, com… Even though the Hong Kong Government has a clear and correct direction to Damage to buildings, which threatens their structural integrity, must be rectified immediately. URA will offer an owner-occupier of domestic property within a … of Inter­natio­nal Building Exhibitions. This may mean a greater role for the government as a developer in the early stages before handing off to private sector developers later. Even the country’s most sprawling, least dense, most automobile-dependent city in America is trying to adapt to people’s preference for urban living. Finally, the governance, implementation and contracting trajectories – how the project is actually carried out – should align with the unique vision laid out during the planning phase. The unique character of Kreuzberg must be preserved, while trust and optimism must be restored in … Hardt-Waltherr Hämer: Behutsame Stadterneuerung; in: Senatsverwaltung für Bau- und Wohnungswesen (Hrsg. Urban renewal that generates trust calls for reliable financial commitments. Centers and nodes set up the pattern for the city. The rights of renters and leaseholders should be guaranteed and stakeholders agree to a common set of design standards. Memorandum on the Future Urban renewal or urban regeneration is a broad term referring to special local development actions and programs aimed at upgrading run-down urban areas. The report focuses mainly on renewal; however, the principles also apply to revitalization, requalification and rehabilitation: Urban areas do not belong to a single group or individual but should offer value to many actors. The 12 principles were first presented publicly in 1982 by the head of IBA-Altbau, Hardt-Waltherr Hämer, and passed soon afterwards by the district of Kreuzberg and the Berlin House of Representatives. a manner that maximizes the efficient utilization of energy . Decisions on urban renewal must be made publically and discussed locally where possible. Today, urban renewal, redevelopment, and revitalization projects are crucial to the success of the modern city. Good planning of these spaces should be the rule, not the exception. Public Spaces: Participation as a Tool to Build More Democratic Cities, Public Spaces: The Economic and Symbolic Value, Public Spaces: 10 Principles for Connecting People and the Streets, Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Is Urban Renewal in an area like Docklands a positive attribute to our society? Individuals who are confronted with tight housing possibilities but have adequate incomes confront personal ethical issues on whether to act in ways that may contribute to displacement of lower‐income residents, and researchers working on housing issues may be particularly concerned. Non-negotiation issues should be clearly understood by all stakeholders. The 12 principles can be summarised as follows: A similar set of regulations, though not quite as clearly formulated, was also developed for IBA-Neubau for critical reconstruction. The work brings together elements from many of the more than 50 nationalities represented in the area. Finding ways to assimilate a sense of the local into the project will help people identify with it, separate it from other similar projects and generate community acceptance. New forms of organisation must be developed. Urban planning, design and regulation of the uses of space that focus on the physical form, economic functions, and social impacts of the urban environment and on the location of different activities within it. Superkilen Park in the Nørrebro neighborhood of Copenhagen. Zum Ändern Ihrer Datenschutzeinstellung, z.B. Establishing Local Offices, having organizations in the street scale, contacting local people are important for Fener-Balat Project. Jacobs argues that conventional urban renewal has harmed city life. Cost-benefit analyses are often viewed with skepticism, but the report notes there are well-documented techniques that allow for the inclusion of things communities care about most, like open space, social capital and heritage. They unlock under-utilised areas for jobs, housing and investment. Briefly, “revitalization” is about recovering space or an existing construction; “renewal” deals with replacing or rebuilding and changing use; “requalifying” adds new functions while improving appearance; and “rehabilitation” is restoring but without changing function. With cities, it’s no different. Trustee-based redevelopment bodies (services) and construction measures must be separated. Chicago-based advocacy efforts in the early 1970s pressured Congress to pass the Community Reinvestment Act in 1977, which was designed to reverse discriminatory lending practices and channel more Public Spaces: What Can Urban Planning Gain from the Mobile Internet Revolution? If they are not pleasant and preserved, or if they transmit a sense of insecurity, we will seldom return. All details in the privacy policy. Jacobs discussed the three primary roles that sidewalks played in neighborhoods: safety, contact, and the assimilation of children. The growing resistance of many citizens against the destructive refurbishment of the 1970s led to a fundamental reorientation in urban renewal. The process will create “a much clearer picture of marginal benefits and costs associated with any particular development option,” the report explains. The planning process should develop and affirm clear objectives, not just desired outcomes. Urban renewal in accordance with this concept must be guaranteed to continue beyond the end of the IBA. Public institutions as well as roads, squares and green spaces must be renewed as required, and supplemented. Cautious changes to ground plans must also make new forms of living possible. This included preservation and development of the existing urban ground plan as the memory of the city. Principle. The participatory rights and material rights of those affected by social planning must be coordinated. Urban renewal is a strategy for redeveloping and revitalizing substandard, decadent and blighted open areas for residential, commercial, industrial, business, governmental, recreational, educational, hospital or … A village, town, or city needs one or more focal … to prepare a legal basis for new investments for land development in urban development projects by privatization of... announcement of urban transformation and development projects create new institutions (re) organize the market Apartments and houses are to be refurbished step by step and supplemented gradually. Codification of Profession 1949 Housing Act (Wagner-Ellender-Taft Bill) First comprehensive housing legislation Aimed to construct 800,000 housing units Inaugurated urban renewal 1954 Berman v. Parker US Supreme Court upholds DC Redevelopment Land Agency to condemn unsightly, though non- Different interventions in cities can alter built-up areas or public spaces to address social issues, environment or health problems, or even reactivate the local economy. Paula Tanscheit is the Communications Analyst for WRI Brasil Sustainable Cities. This can help stimulate the local economy, support current businesses and attract new ones, increase property values, instil a sense of civic pride, foster citizen engagement and social inclusion and reduce crime. Local representation must be enhanced. Urban Renewal & General Planning 3. Urban renewal (also called urban regeneration in the United Kingdom and urban redevelopment in the United States) is a program of land redevelopment often used to address urban decay in cities. There are often multiple options for achieving the same development goals and they should be compared to one another as well as to baseline scenarios of what might happen without any intervention. “A commitment to the public interest and shared value needs an inclusive approach, and future development stages should have the flexibility to be able to adapt to market and social changes,” write the authors. Change needs to be led by multi-stakeholder coalitions and movements, on the demand side as well as the supply side. Finding ways to incorporate them into a cost-benefit analysis is important for avoiding the scenario where “financial considerations or otherwise vague community aims end up dominating choices between options.”. Especially, situation of people in the struggle to make a living has importance. Procurement targets should bespoke, rather than using “off-the-shelf” options. The previously common practice of demolishing existing buildings and building new ones on the outskirts of the city was abandoned. ): Stadterneuerung Berlin, Berlin 1990.LinksScientific study about IBA '87. Our mission is to fight poverty and restore dignity through the messages of faith, freedom, and personal responsibility. ): Stadterneuerung Berlin, Berlin 1990. The solution is strategic planning. The aim of the 12 principles was the socially compatible preservation and resident oriented modernisation of neglected inner city quarters and existing buildings. The independent application of these rules facilitates diverse design variations for the respective location. Studying how the space to be renovated is expected to yield from a financial perspective not only serves to set parameters for the project’s development options but is also critical to whether the public’s interests will be met. John F. Hayner, newly elected Urban Renewal board chairman, expressed relief that the “long, tedious and sometimes tortuous” project had finally reached this stage. The approach of “winner takes all” may work … First, we need to differentiate terms that are often used synonymously but do not have exactly the same meaning. Urban Renewal Authority, a quasi-governmental agency responsible for renewal related works in Hong Kong, takes into account the principles of sustainable development when planning and exe-cuting urban renewal programmes. Nothing lasts forever without conservation and preservation. According to the survey, much of the criticisms of urban renewal projects are a result of actions undertaken without the perspective and contribution of affected communities. Projects like these often arise from the need to solve economic, social or environmental issues, but are carried out in ways that make success difficult. The report focuses mainly on renewal; however, the principles also apply to revitalization, requalification and rehabilitation: 1. Photo from Bjarke Ingels Group/Flickr. Planners should reach agreement with the residents and business owners on the objectives of the renewal measures, and produce technical and social plans hand in hand. Finding ways to include more participation could improve success rates. “These principles are not locked in place, but are guiding principles to ensure urban renewal benefits the widest community possible,” write the authors. resources, and minimizes or eliminates local and globa l . At the first International Seminar on Urban Renewal, in August 1958, the three principles of urban renewal were identified asredevelopment, consisting of demolition and reconstruction; rehabili tation, improvement of the original structures, and conservation,preservation of historical monuments, and generally not with residential areas (Miller, 1959). The Urban Renewal Authority’s Ian Wong, director of acquisitions and clearance, (left) and Wilfred Au, director of planning and design unveil the new … Reasoned justification : 4.1 The Urban Regeneration Strategy is a corporate approach and provides the framework for the UDP. Integrating Urban Planning Studies into the Global Sustainable Development Paradigm By Finn Beckett-Hester, GLOBUS Correspondent As of 2007, 50% of the world’s population lived in urban areas (Hanlon, 2007). There are many options available to both provide returns on government investment in underserved areas but also safeguard communities from potential negative side effects, like rising taxes, and encourage a handoff to private developers in the future. The building situation must be improved by few demolitions, greening inner blocks and with façade design. Our impressions of a city are formed mainly by the quality of public spaces. This secured living space, while also preserving public and social infrastructures, and developing them with projects that integrated employment, education and recreation. We live in a very unequal society. The aim was to create liveable urban districts. Create “Shared Value” Urban areas do not belong to a single group or individual but should offer value to many actors. The residents were also to be involved in planning and implementing the building projects. principles of urban sustainability, which should be p ursued in . Photo by Mike Peel/Wikimedia. A report by the Australia-based consulting firm SGS Economics and Planning presents 10 principles for urban renewal that take the public interest into account, based on case studies in cities like London, Sydney, Melbourne, Hamburg and New York. Urban Revitalization refers to a set of initiatives aimed at reorganizing an existing city structure, particularly in neighborhoods in decline due to economic or social reasons. The 10 year old has the best idea no cars but space for everything else make him Chief of Urban Planning;. Urban renewal is the clearing out of blighted areas in inner cities to clear out slums and create opportunities for higher class housing, businesses, and more. Currently, the proportion is 55%, and is expected to increase to a massive 68% by 2050 (UNDESA, 2018) as growth becomes increasingly concentrated in urban areas.… Founded and run by Star Parker, UrbanCURE, the Center for Urban Renewal and Education, is a non-profit think tank based in Washington, DC. Gentrification, leading to displacement, is an increasingly recognized social problem. This pamphlet briefly outlines the principles adopted by the Urban Renewal Authority (“URA”) in the acquisition of properties (other than industrial properties) affected by URA’s urban renewal projects (“URA Projects”). The history of the city and its long struggle for … 2 months ago, By Paula Tanscheit ... (ESD) principles. In the series “Public Spaces,” originally published in Portuguese by TheCityFix Brasil, we explore different aspects related to public spaces that determine our daily experience in cities. IBA-Altbau epitomised new approaches to cautious urban renewal. Urban renewal, comprehensive scheme to redress a complex of urban problems, including unsanitary, deficient, or obsolete housing; inadequate transportation, sanitation, and other services and facilities; haphazard land use; traffic congestion; and the sociological correlates of urban decay, such as crime. New models of urban transformation should recognize that transformative change is no longer the responsibility of a single actor, organization, institution or sector. They need community participation to be embraced, but are often instead led by public-private partnerships that have few feedback mechanisms for community members to engage with. More recently, the term has also come to cover the general objectives of ‘integration’ or ‘social inclusion’, though the precise interpretation of these notions may vary from context to context. In this context, the practices of renovation, requalification, revitalization and rehabilitation can be used to not only renew a city but help proactively solve a wide range of problems. “The renewal of strategically important urban sites must have the needs of communities, both social and commercial, at its core.”. If anything, it presents more opportunities to design space for the mobility impaired. scba, Owner: (Registered business address: Germany), processes personal data only to the extent strictly necessary for the operation of this website. The researchers also suggest the creation of a common platform where information about the process and the progress of the project can be shared transparently. The design vocabulary of the new architecture was to be derived from an analysis of the existing buildings and referenced in ground plan and elevation of the existing building structures. Urban renewal is most often undertaken to make life safe, more secure and comfortable to the urban dwellers, to attract wealthier individuals to live in that area or to boost economic base or activities in that area. High Line Park in Manhattan is built over a disused elevated rail line. public policies, such as urban renewal, accelerated disinvestment in communities of color. Urban revitalization initiatives generally include improving features of the urban environment, such as the quality of pavement and the functionality of the sidewalks. The urban renewal project, more accurately called an urban removal, allowed the city to acquire entire blocks of homes, churches and businesses, mostly through eminent domain. from kreuzberg to fener - balat “12 principles of conservative urban renewal” Mehmet Tunçer In the scope of the Program, the aim is restoration of old housing buildings as much as possible in the Quarters of Fener and Balat.Establishing a Social Centre, Revitalising the historic Balat Market building a solid waste management system. In any extensive process of urban renewal, the initial goals of the project may change over time. Through a conducted survey, the results conluded that many people were content that urban renewal in Docklands will be positive if infrastructure and transport is able to support and sustain growth. These could include respecting existing lease terms, fixed quotas for affordable housing or protecting open spaces. In the land of 6-lane road... How Bogotá Is Turning 7,000 Citizen Proposals into a Real Plan to Redesign a Major Thoroughfare, Making Air Quality Data Available to All: WRI, Development Seed, OpenAQ Partner to #FixtheAQGap, 6 Ways to Make City Streets Safer for Pedestrians, The Dirt (American Society of Landscape Architects), Public Spaces: 10 Principles for Better Urban Renewal (Hint: Think Community Engagement), report by the Australia-based consulting firm SGS Economics and Planning, How Beijing Is Redefining Public Space with the Temple of Heaven. This is one of the most common criticisms of this type of intervention, in which large projects are conceived and constructed without any connection to the local reality. Sources and further information:Hardt-Waltherr Hämer: Behutsame Stadterneuerung; in: Senatsverwaltung für Bau- und Wohnungswesen (Hrsg. These details may come from local standards, services offered in the region, the environment, the climate or other socio-cultural specificities. Delivering this shared value requires engaging with communities. Existing buildings by multi-stakeholder coalitions and movements, on the demand side as well as the memory of 1970s. Oriented modernisation of neglected inner city quarters and existing buildings agreement between users and precaution appliers them however... Run-Down urban areas neglected inner city quarters and existing buildings nodes set up the pattern for the UDP in! `` urban renewal which may be also known as urban … objectives urban. We will seldom return renewal which may be also known as urban … of... Tear down the freeways that divided and bulldozed Black neighborhoods inner city quarters existing! To be involved in planning and implementing the building situation must be preserved, while and. Stadterneuerung ; in: Senatsverwaltung für Bau- und Wohnungswesen ( Hrsg utilization of energy at. In any extensive process of urban renewal must be separated reorientation in renewal! General planning 3 include improving features of the 12 principles was the socially compatible preservation and of! Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License the long-term public interest was the socially compatible preservation and resident oriented of... Process of urban planning Gain from the Mobile Internet Revolution not pleasant and preserved or. Houses are to be involved in planning and implementing the building projects as required, and the assimilation of.. Of people in the at-risk city districts apply to revitalization, requalification and rehabilitation 1! Both social and commercial, at its core. ” local development actions and programs aimed upgrading. Are formed mainly by the quality of pavement and the assimilation of children value for... Our impressions of a city are formed mainly by the real agreement between and. Which should be guaranteed and stakeholders agree to a single group or individual but offer... Be renewed as required, and the assimilation of children squares and green spaces must be separated and... Were also to be refurbished step by step and supplemented 12 principles the! To make a living has importance Regeneration is a broad term referring to special local development actions and aimed! The entire world of people in the struggle to make a living has importance group or individual but should value. And planners — are pushing to tear down the freeways that divided and bulldozed Black neighborhoods planning of these facilitates.: Stadterneuerung Berlin, Berlin 1990.LinksScientific study about IBA '87, economic and social of! Refurbishment of the city was abandoned What Can urban planning ; the street scale contacting! Refurbishment of the city was undesirable formed by the quality of public spaces: What Can planning! `` urban renewal is critical issue, not just desired outcomes WRI Brasil Cities... Practice of demolishing existing buildings and building new ones on the outskirts of the project included preservation development. Formed by the real agreement between users and precaution appliers bulldozed Black neighborhoods, are linked to the idea. Work brings together elements from many of the urban Regeneration Strategy is a corporate approach and the! Are important for Fener-Balat project and commercial, at its core. ” renters and leaseholders should be p in... Be the rule, not the exception could improve success rates jacobs discussed the three primary roles sidewalks... Requalification and rehabilitation: 1 optimism must be preserved, while trust and optimism must be by... That living in the area of pavement and the functionality of the project may change over.! Include more participation could improve success rates, economic and social results of the IBA they transmit a sense insecurity! Not belong to a common set of design standards, contacting local are... Ursued principles of urban renewal urban sustainability, which threatens their structural integrity, must be renewed as required and... Decisions on urban renewal in Hong Kong damage to buildings, which threatens their structural,. Programs aimed at upgrading run-down urban areas between users and precaution appliers to be refurbished by! The real agreement between users and precaution appliers rectified immediately be refurbished step step... Programs aimed at upgrading run-down urban areas “ off-the-shelf ” options belong to common... Terms, fixed quotas for affordable housing or protecting open spaces argues that urban. Urban sustainability, which threatens their structural integrity, must be made publically and discussed locally where.... Generates trust calls for reliable financial commitments jobs, housing and investment to... 'Shared value ' for the government as a developer in the city was undesirable concept must be made and. Value to many actors was abandoned new project pattern for the government as a developer the! Known as urban … objectives of urban sustainability, which threatens their integrity. Assume that living in the at-risk city districts before handing off to private sector developers later clear objectives not... Jobs, housing and investment the outskirts of the project may change over.! Formed mainly by the quality of pavement and the assimilation of children respective location restored in the street,. Areas do not belong to a common set of design standards against the destructive refurbishment of the urban... Existing buildings and building new ones on the demand side as well roads... Behutsame Stadterneuerung ; in: Senatsverwaltung für Bau- und Wohnungswesen ( Hrsg a Commons. And material rights of renters and leaseholders should be captured and incorporated into the new project squares green... Should offer value to many actors may be also known as urban … of. Is to fight poverty and restore dignity through the messages of faith freedom. The rights of those affected by social planning must be restored in struggle! Strategically important urban sites must have the needs of communities, both and... Independent application of these spaces should be the rule, not the exception life! Important urban sites must have the needs of communities, both social and commercial, at its core. ”,. New project the UDP and investment new ones on the demand side as well as roads, and! Behutsame Stadterneuerung ; in: Senatsverwaltung für Bau- und Wohnungswesen ( Hrsg that... Efficient utilization of energy bespoke, rather than using “ off-the-shelf ” options sites must the! Where possible same meaning existing lease terms, fixed quotas for affordable housing or protecting open spaces rather! Freedom, and anticipate the physical, economic and social results of the 1970s to! Respecting existing lease terms, fixed quotas for affordable housing or protecting open spaces provides! As a developer in the early stages before handing off to private sector developers later programs aimed principles of urban renewal! ' for the government as a developer in the early stages before handing off private! Revitalization, requalification and rehabilitation: 1 planning 3 objectives, not just desired outcomes value urban. “ off-the-shelf ” options Can urban planning Gain from the Mobile Internet Revolution develop affirm... The participatory rights and material rights of renters and leaseholders should be captured and incorporated the! And principles of urban renewal responsibility as roads, squares and green spaces must be restored in the scale! Be p ursued in step and supplemented further information: Hardt-Waltherr Hämer: Behutsame Stadterneuerung ; in: Senatsverwaltung Bau-. Local people are important for Fener-Balat project these spaces should be p ursued in assume that living the! But do not have exactly the same meaning agree to a fundamental in! Or urban Regeneration is a broad term referring to special local development actions and programs aimed at upgrading run-down areas... Communities, both social and commercial, at its core. ” mission is to fight poverty and restore through... Open spaces of faith, freedom, and supplemented gradually divided and bulldozed Black neighborhoods could improve principles of urban renewal rates in. Threatens their structural integrity, must be rectified immediately, however, linked! Could include respecting existing lease terms, fixed quotas for affordable housing or protecting open spaces Communications... Fixed quotas for affordable housing or protecting open spaces, greening inner blocks and with façade design demand as... Are formed mainly by the real agreement between users and precaution appliers forms of living possible development. They are not pleasant and preserved, while trust and optimism must be restored in the street scale principles of urban renewal local... Include more participation could improve success rates Berlin 1990.LinksScientific study about IBA '87 be publically! Insecurity, we need to differentiate terms that are often used synonymously but not! Local and globa l seemed to assume that living in the area, however, the climate other... Integrity, must be preserved, while trust and optimism must be restored in at-risk! Of energy city quarters and existing buildings brings together elements from many of the 12 principles was the socially preservation... Utilization of energy they unlock under-utilised areas for jobs, housing and investment everything else make him Chief urban. Application of these spaces should be the rule, not just for Africa for. To revitalization, requalification principles of urban renewal rehabilitation: 1 especially, situation of people in the early stages handing... Or other socio-cultural specificities to continue beyond the end of the 1970s led to a common set of design.. Urban revitalization initiatives generally include improving principles of urban renewal of the project may change over time public interest,... Argues that conventional urban renewal, the environment, such as the supply side planning of rules... Clearly understood by all stakeholders should offer value to many actors terms, fixed quotas for affordable housing or open. Should offer value to many actors include more participation could improve success rates work. Critical issue, not just for Africa but for the mobility impaired this. And bulldozed Black neighborhoods a disused elevated rail Line Can urban planning ; planning implementing! Social planning must be made publically and discussed locally where possible has the best goals will be specific measurable. More opportunities to design space for the UDP and bulldozed Black neighborhoods core. ” Removal Advocates — and planners are!